Back when I originally posted about my first success making Dole Whip at home, I was happy enough just to get the flavor right. But even then, I knew the consistency was way off. My homemade Dole Whip was icy and more like pineapple granita than true Dole Whip.
Can’t wait to have some Dole Whip? Buy authentic Dole Whip mix on Amazon.
Since then, I’ve tried several approaches to improving the consistency, including pre-cooling the mix to lower the chill time and even adding milk to the otherwise non-dairy Dole Whip to give it a more ice cream-like texture (this was a disaster).
The solution hit me today — maybe there’s actually a reason why they call it Dole Whip. The instructions that came with the mix didn’t say anything about whipping the finished product, but I gave it a shot and it turned out next to perfect!
Here are the steps to near-perfect Dole Whip at home:
- Buy Pineapple Dole Whip mix from these guys.
- Get an Ice Cream Maker with a compressor.
- Follow the directions to make the mix (half-quart cold water, whisk in 1 1/3 cups Dole mix, fill to 1 quart of water, stir)
- Pour the mix in the ice cream maker and let it process until it has an slightly icy soft serve texture.
- Freeze the Dole Whip. It’ll harden like a granita.
- Mash up the frozen Dole Whip a bit with a spoon and process for a minute or two with a handheld mixer.
In my single attempt so far, I ended up with a much fluffier and smoother Dole Whip that was far less icy but still thick enough to be scooped onto a cone. Perfect Dole Whip at home is still just a dream, but we’re getting closer.